Jordan Blum – S&P Global Platts – HOUSTON — US commercial crude storage could hit its capacity in mid-May as refinery demand and US oil exports each plunge about 30%, triggering widespread production cuts and shut-ins throughout the country, according to Plains All American Pipeline.
The major US crude pipeline operator wrote a letter this week to the Texas energy regulator in advance of the Texas Railroad Commission’s emergency meeting Tuesday to discuss potentially mandating production reductions in the state because of collapsing global demand amid the coronavirus pandemic.
In late March, Plains began asking crude oil producers to start reducing output to keep the US from rapidly running out of crude storage space, which would cause a deeper crash in US oil prices.
“We estimate that US refinery demand for crude oil would be reduced by 30% or more, an approximate 5 million b/d decline. We also estimated that crude oil exports will likely be reduced by a similar percentage, which represents an additional demand reduction of approximately 1 million b/d,” Plains President Harry Pefanis wrote this week. “We believed that commercial crude storage would absorb the imbalance for a period of time (mid-May, by our estimates), but that at some point curtailments of US production would be required to balance the market.”
US production already has fallen from an estimated 13 million b/d to below 12.4 million b/d, according to the US Energy Information Administration, but much greater reductions are expected.
“Against this backdrop, we have been advising our producer customers to proactively manage their exposure by taking steps to reduce or curtail production in a manner that was best suited for their assets rather than waiting for storage capacity to be filled and being forced to shut-in production,” Pefanis added. “Some of the proactive measures we suggested producers could implement quickly included deferring completions and where practicable, choking back production.”
EYES ON TEXAS
Large, independent Permian Basin producers Pioneer Natural Resources and Parsley Energy have pushed Texas to implement mandatory production cuts for the first time in nearly 50 years, but most producers are in opposition, including ExxonMobil, Chevron, Occidental Petroleum, EOG Resources, Marathon Oil, Concho Resources, Diamondback Energy and Devon Energy. They have all argued in favor of letting free markets work and the reductions will come naturally.
Although any mandatory reductions in Texas are considered unlikely because of the large base of opposition, the meeting will come after the OPEC+ group has tentatively agreed to scale back production by 10 million b/d in May and June as Saudi Arabia and Russia ended their month-long pricing war. The US, Canada, and others are supporting the OPEC+ deal at Friday’s G20 meeting of energy ministers.
US producers that oppose mandatory reductions point out that companies are slicing their spending more than 30% on average and pulling drilling rigs from the oilfields at a record pace.
“Indications are that production in Texas, and across the nation, is already headed toward a dramatic decline in response to the pandemic and price war, as evidenced by the reported reductions in individual operator capital budgets, as well as the material decrease in the number of active drilling rigs,” Concho stated in a letter.
“In fact, Concho, as well as other operators in the Permian Basin, have begun shutting in uneconomic production in rapid response to the recent market shift. Once the market moves toward equilibrium, commodity prices will respond accordingly.”
Continental Resources founder and chairman Harold Hamm, a key energy ally of President Donald Trump, joined Pioneer and Parsley in supporting the required cutbacks, but Continental doesn’t operate in Texas.
Texas Railroad Commissioner Ryan Sitton has most publicly pushed for state intervention, although even he has said he has mixed feelings on the topic. The goal is to prevent uneconomic “wasteful production” of crude oil at a time when global supplies are far outpacing demand, Sitton said, adding,”it’s my job to consider this.”