Oil & Gas News

Supreme Court ruling on Oklahoma tribal land raises questions for oil industry

Oklahoma, Supreme Court Ruling, Oklahoma

Reuters – A U.S. Supreme Court decision recognizing about half of Oklahoma as Native American reservation land has implications for oil and gas development in the state, raising complex regulatory and tax questions that could take years to settle, according to Oklahoma attorneys.

On July 8th, the court overturned an Oklahoma tribe member’s rape conviction because the location where the crime was committed should have been considered reservation land and therefore outside the reach of state criminal law.

The decision does not affect property ownership, but attorneys said it has regulatory and tax implications within reservation lands of the state’s “Five Tribes” – Cherokee, Chickasaw, Choctaw, Creek and Seminole. Oklahoma was the fourth-largest U.S. crude oil producer last year, accounting for about 5% of production, according to government data.

“You’ll see the Five Tribes make arguments perhaps that they have taxation authority,” said Taiawagi Helton, who teaches environmental, property and Indian law at the University of Oklahoma. “It’s possible you could see some slight increases in taxation,” with companies paying production taxes to both the state and tribes.

“For pipeline approvals, tribes will expect to have a broader consultative role,” Helton said.

Tribes may not want to immediately act, but this case suggests they would have regulatory authority over oil and gas, said Oklahoma energy attorney A.J. Ferate.

“Do I suspect anybody is going to get their existing production taken away? I think that would be a very extreme issue,” Ferate said.

“We’re talking about decades of litigation and questions. We’re in a whole new world here in Oklahoma as to how do all of these pieces fit together and how do we move forward,” he said.

Mike McBride III, chair of Indian law at Tulsa law firm Crowe and Dunlevy, said there may be implications for wind energy and electric transmission as well as sales of water.

Industry group the Petroleum Alliance of Oklahoma said it hoped there would be no change from current regulation.

“It is critical for continued investment in Oklahoma that the state maintain primacy with regard to the regulation of oil and gas operations, and that issues of title with regard to real property remain unaffected,” it said in a statement.

The Petroleum Alliance and other business groups had opposed the recognition of reservation status in a brief to the Supreme Court arguing that it would “recast the business and legal environment” across lands of all Five Tribes.

The Five Tribes and the state issued a joint statement on Thursday that they were working together on a framework of shared jurisdiction to “support public safety, our economy and private property rights.”

The crossroads of energy information for minerals owners in Oklahoma. Where you can: See recent prices of mineral and lease transactions. Receive an offer to lease or buy your minerals.

Find relevant news stories on the most active areas, including the Scoop and Stack Plays.

Data Powered by Oseberg

Today’s E&P world is rapidly shifting towards data-driven decision making, but those decisions are only as good as the data behind them. Access Oseberg's deep, accurate, and detailed pool of insight-rich industry data with our powerful analytical and search tools and get the clearest picture of what's happening as soon as it happens.


This web site is maintained solely for the personal use of our visitors. Although we at Oklahoma Minerals have made all reasonable efforts to provide accurate information, we cannot guarantee the completeness, timeliness or accuracy of the information contained herein. Nothing in this web site contains investment advice. Any decisions based upon the information contained in this web site are the sole responsibility of the user.

Copyright © 2021 OklahomaMinerals.com

To Top
ConocoPhillips Says USA Regulations Hold Back SupplyRead More